Sunday 22 November 2026 Live: Iran war Stories Browse Wire Subscribe
Faultline Journal — home

AmericasDevelopingDay 6

Melbourne Cup horse found in Sydney bin

So You Are, who finished eighth in the Melbourne Cup on 3 November and won eight of 29 starts for A$1.4 million, was put down after severe colic and found.

Updated 21:29 UTC, 17 November 2026 · 5 reports from 3 outlets · 6 confirmed · 20 one-source

Read it your way

Loading the summary…

Written by AI only from the receipts on this page; each number links to the claim that line rests on.

What changed

Last 48 hours

Nothing new in the last 48 hours.

How it’s being told

One card per media bloc, with each outlet’s framing written from its own headlines.

European media

EuronewsPrivateThe GuardianNon-profitBBCPublic broadcaster

  • Euronews foregrounds the discovery of the dumped remains and the 'distress' voiced by trainer and public, quoting questions like 'Does anyone know if that's legal?' while giving little.
  • The Guardian centres the owner's demand that 'heads have got to roll' and a 'full investigation' into the disposal, foregrounding accountability and the veterinary practice's 'full responsibility' while.
  • BBC foregrounds the discovery of the horse's body in a Sydney skip bin, centring the 'dumped' remains rather than the trainer's stated distress or the colic that led to the horse being put down.

In their words

What the people at the centre of this story said, word for word, with the article each quote appeared in.

There should be a full investigation. Heads have got to roll - simple as that

RamseyquoteThe GuardianReceipt

a licensed landfill is the preferred option for animals who have died via euthanasia due to the chemicals involved in the process

Racing NSWregulating body in the state of New South WalesEuronewsReceipt

distress … promptly and respectfully buried.

So You AreEuronewsReceipt

deeply distressed by the handling of So You Are's remains.

BakerEuronewsReceipt

That can't be normal. Does anyone know if that's legal? … I'm disgusted by that.

Gregg JowettquoteEuronewsReceipt

severe bout of colic.

Trainer Bjorn BakerEuronewsReceipt

I understand the hospital facility REC Equine Specialists are investigating the circumstances, and I expect a full explanation of what occurred.

Bjorn BakerThe GuardianReceipt

Receipts

Every claim with the verbatim sentence it came from. Tap a claim to see its sources.

Confirmed 6

Reported by at least two independent outlets, or by the actor itself.

So You Are won eight of his 29 starts and earned A$1.4 million in prize money. Confirmed by 2Euronews, The Guardian · #
So You Are finished eighth in the Melbourne Cup on 3 November. Confirmed by 2Euronews, The Guardian · #
The body of a Melbourne Cup horse was found dumped in a Sydney skip bin. Confirmed by 2BBC, Euronews · #
Trainer Bjorn Baker says he is deeply distressed by the apparent handling of So You Are's remains. Confirmed by 2The Guardian, Euronews · #
So You Are was put down after suffering a severe bout of colic. Confirmed by 2The Guardian, Euronews · #
So You Are placed eighth in the Melbourne Cup two weeks before the discovery. Confirmed by 2The Guardian, Euronews · #

One source 20

Only one outlet so far. Shown, never hidden — treat with care.

REC managing partner Jonathan Lumsden says the practice took full responsibility for choosing the service provider and arrangements. One source: The GuardianThe Guardian · #
Ramsey says there should be a full investigation and heads have got to roll. One source: The GuardianThe Guardian · #
Racing NSW says its investigations found So You Are was being held temporarily awaiting burial when the footage was recorded. One source: The GuardianThe Guardian · #
So You Are was euthanised under anaesthesia after surgery could not save the horse. One source: The GuardianThe Guardian · #
Stuart Ramsey says it is a "bloody disgrace" the gelding was left in the skip bin while awaiting burial. One source: The GuardianThe Guardian · #
So You Are's owner-breeder demands a full investigation after the Melbourne Cup runner's body was found in a skip at a Sydney tip. One source: The GuardianThe Guardian · #
Racing NSW says NSW Department of Primary Industries guidelines make a licensed landfill the preferred option for animals euthanised due to the chemicals involved. One source: EuronewsEuronews · #
  • “Racing NSW, the regulating body in the state of New South Wales, said that under NSW Department of Primary Industries guidelines,"a licensed landfill is the preferred option for animals who have died via euthanasia due to the chemicals involved in the process," per Australian media.”

    EuronewsPrivateAttributesDead Melbourne Cup racehorse found dumped in Sydney waste facility

REC Equine Specialists says it has stopped using the contracted provider effective immediately. One source: EuronewsEuronews · #
REC Equine Specialists apologised for the distress caused by the footage. One source: EuronewsEuronews · #
Gregg Jowett posted footage of the discovery and said he was disgusted. One source: EuronewsEuronews · #
Trainer Bjorn Baker announced on Monday that So You Are died following a severe bout of colic. One source: EuronewsEuronews · #
REC Equine Specialists apologised over the handling of So You Are's remains. One source: EuronewsEuronews · #
REC Equine Specialists says So You Are should have been promptly and respectfully buried. One source: EuronewsEuronews · #
REC Equine Specialists says So You Are was collected by its contracted service provider and taken to a licensed landfill. One source: EuronewsEuronews · #
The body of So You Are, a Melbourne Cup runner, was found in an industrial waste bin near Sydney. One source: EuronewsEuronews · #
Bjorn Baker says he expects a full explanation of what occurred from REC Equine Specialists. One source: The GuardianThe Guardian · #
Gregg Jowett posted a video on Monday showing a dead horse inside a skip bin in Sydney. One source: The GuardianThe Guardian · #
So You Are was taken to hospital on Monday for surgery. One source: The GuardianThe Guardian · #
So You Are was a five-year-old gelding. One source: The GuardianThe Guardian · #
The body of the racehorse So You Are was found dumped in a skip bin in Sydney. One source: The GuardianThe Guardian · #

Ask about this story

Line, our AI correspondent, answers only from the receipts on this page. Every sentence links to the claim behind it.

Ghost edits

Changes outlets made to their articles after publishing, caught by re-reading them.

  • The GuardianSubstantive edit

    Headline‘Heads should roll’: owner of Melbourne Cup horse found dumped in skip bin demands investigation

    Ramsey quote changed to "said racehorses were"; added "He meant so much to us"; added Minns quotes and NSW landfill disposal detail; "tragic case" cut to "case".

    RemovedStuart Ramsey says it is a ‘bloody disgrace’ the gelding was left in the skip bin while awaiting burial Get our breaking news email , free app or daily news podcast So You Are’s owner-breeder has demanded a full investigation after the…

    AddedStuart Ramsey says it is a ‘bloody disgrace’ the gelding was left in waste container while awaiting burial Get our breaking news email , free app or daily news podcast So You Are’s owner-breeder has demanded a full investigation after the…

    Read the article as it stands now

  • The GuardianSubstantive edit

    Before‘Heads should roll’: owner of Melbourne Cup horse found dumped in skip bin demands probe

    After‘Heads should roll’: owner of Melbourne Cup horse found dumped in skip bin demands investigation

    Headline "probe" changed to "investigation"; "November 3" changed to "3 November"; added quote: "He meant so much to us," he said.

    RemovedBjorn Baker’s promising stayer took ill at a spelling farm after finishing eighth in Australia’s most famous race on November 3.

    AddedBjorn Baker’s promising stayer took ill at a spelling farm after finishing eighth in Australia’s most famous race on 3 November.

    Read the article as it stands now

  • The GuardianSubstantive edit

    Headline‘Disgusted by it’: body of Melbourne Cup race horse found dumped in Sydney skip bin

    Melbourne Cup added before race; "five year old Gelding" changed to "five-year-old gelding"; quote split and reordered; added note on not publishing video and REC Equine's Dr Jonathan Lumsden apology.

    RemovedSo You Are placed eighth in race just two weeks ago and was put down after a severe bout of colic The body of a horse that placed eighth in the Melbourne Cup two weeks ago and recently fell ill has been found dumped in skip bin in Sydney.

    AddedSo You Are placed eighth in race just two weeks ago and was put down after a severe bout of colic Get our daily political email , free app or daily news podcast The body of a horse that placed eighth in Australia’s Melbourne Cup two weeks…

    Read the article as it stands now

All sources

5 reports from 3 outlets — with who owns each outlet and who pays for it.

Euronews Private

FranceOwner: Alpac Capital (majority shareholder since 2022)Paid by: advertising + distribution; has held EU institutional service contracts

The Guardian Non-profit

United KingdomOwner: Guardian Media Group, owned by the Scott Trust LimitedPaid by: reader contributions + subscriptions + advertising; Scott Trust endowment

BBC Public broadcaster

United KingdomOwner: BBC — public corporation under Royal CharterPaid by: TV licence fee

Not covered yet by

Al JazeeraArs TechnicaAssociated PressCGTNCNADWESPNFinancial TimesForeign PolicyFox NewsFrance 24NPRRTReutersSky NewsSky SportsSouth China Morning PostSputnikTASSTRT WorldTechCrunchThe New York TimesThe Times of IndiaThe VergeWION

Outlets we monitor that have not reported this story. Silence can be signal.

From the Faultline desk

Our analysis pieces on this story.

Read the AI explainer

6 confirmed · 20 one-source3 outletsUpdated