Sunday 22 November 2026 Live: Iran war Stories Browse Wire Subscribe
Faultline Journal — home

AI explainer

Melbourne Cup horse So You Are found in Sydney skip bin

The body of Melbourne Cup runner So You Are was found in a Sydney skip bin after the horse was put down following a severe bout of colic.

AI-written from the receipts on this page. Every factual sentence links to the claim it comes from on Melbourne Cup horse found in Sydney bin; contested claims give both sides and one-source claims are labelled. Generated 4 days ago · deepseek/deepseek-flash

What happened

So You Are, a five-year-old gelding, finished eighth in the Melbourne Cup on 3 November 12. Two weeks later, the horse's body was found dumped in a skip bin in Sydney 34. The horse had been put down after suffering a severe bout of colic 5. Trainer Bjorn Baker said he was deeply distressed by the apparent handling of So You Are's remains 6.

What is confirmed

According to confirmed reports, So You Are won eight of his 29 starts and earned A$1.4 million in prize money 7. He finished eighth in the Melbourne Cup on 3 November 1. The body of a Melbourne Cup horse was found dumped in a Sydney skip bin 3. So You Are was put down after suffering a severe bout of colic 5. Trainer Bjorn Baker said he is deeply distressed by the apparent handling of the horse's remains 6.

Where the accounts differ

The ledger contains no contested claims. The media blocs do not present differing accounts of the core events; both Euronews and The Guardian report the confirmed claims 173652.

What is not known yet

Several details are reported by single outlets. The horse was a five-year-old gelding, reported only by The Guardian 8. So You Are was taken to hospital on Monday for surgery, reported only by The Guardian 9. Surgery could not save the horse and he was euthanised under anaesthesia, reported only by The Guardian 10. Gregg Jowett posted a video on Monday showing a dead horse inside a skip bin in Sydney, reported only by The Guardian 11. Jowett said he was disgusted, reported only by Euronews 12. Racing NSW said its investigations found So You Are was being held temporarily awaiting burial when the footage was recorded, reported only by The Guardian 13. Stuart Ramsey said it is a 'bloody disgrace' the gelding was left in the skip bin while awaiting burial, reported only by The Guardian 14. Ramsey also said there should be a full investigation and heads have got to roll, reported only by The Guardian 15. So You Are's owner-breeder demanded a full investigation, reported only by The Guardian 16. REC Equine Specialists apologised for the distress caused by the footage and said the horse should have been promptly and respectfully buried, reported only by Euronews 171819. REC said it has stopped using the contracted provider effective immediately, reported only by Euronews 20. REC managing partner Jonathan Lumsden said the practice took full responsibility for choosing the service provider and arrangements, reported only by The Guardian 21. REC said So You Are was collected by its contracted service provider and taken to a licensed landfill, reported only by Euronews 22. Racing NSW said NSW Department of Primary Industries guidelines make a licensed landfill the preferred option for animals euthanised due to the chemicals involved, reported only by Euronews 23. Bjorn Baker said he expects a full explanation from REC Equine Specialists, reported only by The Guardian 24. Baker announced on Monday that So You Are died following a severe bout of colic, reported only by Euronews 25. The body was found in an industrial waste bin near Sydney, reported only by Euronews 26. Open questions remain about the circumstances of the horse's death and the handling of its remains.

Why it matters

The discovery of a Melbourne Cup runner's body in a skip bin has prompted expressions of distress from the trainer 6 and demands for a full investigation from the owner-breeder 1615. This suggests scrutiny of the veterinary practice's arrangements for disposing of euthanised animals 2122. If confirmed, the account that the horse was being held temporarily awaiting burial 13 may raise questions about the handling of remains. Analysis: the case has drawn attention to the regulatory framework for animal disposal, with Racing NSW citing guidelines that a licensed landfill is the preferred option 23.

Opinion

Faultline's view

The confirmed facts are grim enough: a Melbourne Cup runner was put down after colic and its body ended up in a Sydney skip bin. The trainer's distress is on the record, and the owner-breeder's call for a full investigation is understandable. But the ledger shows how quickly a single outlet's reporting can shape the narrative. The claim that the horse was being held temporarily awaiting burial comes only from The Guardian, citing Racing NSW. The veterinary practice's apology and its account that the horse was taken to a licensed landfill come only from Euronews. Until these accounts are independently verified, the full picture remains unclear. What is clear is that the handling of So You Are's remains has caused distress and demands answers, not just from the practice but from the regulators who set the guidelines.

This section is Faultline’s opinion, argued only from the receipts above. It is not part of the factual record and cites nothing new.

Claims cited

  1. So You Are finished eighth in the Melbourne Cup on 3 November. Confirmed
  2. So You Are placed eighth in the Melbourne Cup two weeks before the discovery. Confirmed
  3. The body of a Melbourne Cup horse was found dumped in a Sydney skip bin. Confirmed
  4. The body of the racehorse So You Are was found dumped in a skip bin in Sydney. One source
  5. So You Are was put down after suffering a severe bout of colic. Confirmed
  6. Trainer Bjorn Baker says he is deeply distressed by the apparent handling of So You Are's remains. Confirmed
  7. So You Are won eight of his 29 starts and earned A$1.4 million in prize money. Confirmed
  8. So You Are was a five-year-old gelding. One source
  9. So You Are was taken to hospital on Monday for surgery. One source
  10. So You Are was euthanised under anaesthesia after surgery could not save the horse. One source
  11. Gregg Jowett posted a video on Monday showing a dead horse inside a skip bin in Sydney. One source
  12. Gregg Jowett posted footage of the discovery and said he was disgusted. One source
  13. Racing NSW says its investigations found So You Are was being held temporarily awaiting burial when the footage was recorded. One source
  14. Stuart Ramsey says it is a "bloody disgrace" the gelding was left in the skip bin while awaiting burial. One source
  15. Ramsey says there should be a full investigation and heads have got to roll. One source
  16. So You Are's owner-breeder demands a full investigation after the Melbourne Cup runner's body was found in a skip at a Sydney tip. One source
  17. REC Equine Specialists apologised for the distress caused by the footage. One source
  18. REC Equine Specialists says So You Are should have been promptly and respectfully buried. One source
  19. REC Equine Specialists apologised over the handling of So You Are's remains. One source
  20. REC Equine Specialists says it has stopped using the contracted provider effective immediately. One source
  21. REC managing partner Jonathan Lumsden says the practice took full responsibility for choosing the service provider and arrangements. One source
  22. REC Equine Specialists says So You Are was collected by its contracted service provider and taken to a licensed landfill. One source
  23. Racing NSW says NSW Department of Primary Industries guidelines make a licensed landfill the preferred option for animals euthanised due to the chemicals involved. One source
  24. Bjorn Baker says he expects a full explanation of what occurred from REC Equine Specialists. One source
  25. Trainer Bjorn Baker announced on Monday that So You Are died following a severe bout of colic. One source
  26. The body of So You Are, a Melbourne Cup runner, was found in an industrial waste bin near Sydney. One source

Sources

← Back to the story and every receipt