Sunday 22 November 2026 Live: Iran war Stories Browse Wire Subscribe
Faultline Journal — home

DiplomacyAnalysis

South China Sea Code Stalls Again as ASEAN and Beijing Differ

Manila's summit ends without a conduct pact, with roughly 80 percent of a draft agreed but binding force still contested.

South China Sea Code Stalls Again as ASEAN and Beijing Differ

Image: Al Jazeera

Reporting drawn from Al Jazeera. Analysis and editorial framing by the Faultline Journal Editorial Desk.

The gap matters because the code is the principal diplomatic instrument available for managing a sea where overlapping claims have produced repeated confrontations.

China and the Association of Southeast Asian Nations have failed to conclude their long-running negotiations on a code of conduct for the South China Sea, according to Al Jazeera, despite tentative agreement on about 80 percent of a draft. The Philippines' foreign minister, Theresa Lazaro, told reporters at the ASEAN summit in Manila on Sunday that "there is no conclusion yet", adding that several key issues remain unresolved, including whether the code would be legally binding.

The gap matters because the code is the principal diplomatic instrument available for managing a sea where overlapping claims have produced repeated confrontations. ASEAN and Beijing have worked on the text for more than two decades. The Philippines, as chair of the 11-nation association, had pledged to accelerate the process and reach a deal by the end of this year. That deadline has now slipped, and Lazaro said she still hoped the code could be concluded under Singapore's auspices when the city-state takes over the chair next year.

The unresolved question of legal force goes to the heart of the dispute. Southeast Asian nations want the code to reflect international law, which some of them accuse China of ignoring; Beijing insists its actions have been lawful and professional. Lazaro acknowledged that the parties hold "different views on how things are". China claims most of the South China Sea, clashing with the exclusive economic zones of Brunei, Indonesia, Malaysia, the Philippines and Vietnam. An international arbitration tribunal ruled in 2016 that China's sweeping claims have no basis under international law, a decision Beijing rejects.

The practical stakes are highest between China and the Philippines, which have faced off in a series of maritime confrontations in recent years. Manila accuses Chinese ships of repeated aggressive actions inside its exclusive economic zone, including dangerous manoeuvres, firing water cannons and disrupting resupply missions. China accuses the Philippines of intruding on its territory. Tensions escalated after President Ferdinand Marcos Jr took office in 2022, and months of harsh words preceded this weekend's meetings. A functional code is seen by Southeast Asian governments as essential to keeping such encounters from escalating.

The Manila meetings also produced a separate rebuke on Myanmar. ASEAN extended a ban on the country's leader attending the bloc's annual summits, saying Myanmar had failed to comply with a 2021 peace plan, and leaders decried attacks on civilians by the military and armed groups in the civil war. Under the ban, Myanmar can be represented only by lower-level career diplomats. Lazaro, who is also ASEAN's special envoy to Myanmar, said there were "still certain bombings and displacement of Myanmar people" and that the bloc would monitor how the issue is tackled step by step.

What remains unconfirmed is the substance of the unresolved provisions beyond legal bindingness, and whether Singapore can succeed where Manila did not. The 80 percent figure is Lazaro's characterisation; no text has been published. The code's fate now rests on a chairmanship transition and on whether Beijing will accept constraints it has so far resisted.

South China SeaASEANChinaPhilippinesmaritime dispute