The Security Council, with its permanent members and the veto, embodies that idea, he said.
A trilateral meeting of the leaders of Russia, China and the United States at the APEC summit in Shenzhen has been described as laying the foundation for reform of the United Nations. The assessment came from Jeffrey Sachs, director of the Center for Sustainable Development at Columbia University, in an interview with TASS published as the summit concluded.
Sachs told the Russian state news agency that the meeting was "historic and very positive" and the first occasion on which the three leaders had gathered together. He said he hoped its Declaration toward Peace would mark the start of a concert of the major powers, and argued that such an arrangement would fulfil the original vision of the United Nations as Franklin Roosevelt conceived it. According to Sachs, Roosevelt did not envisage a world government but favoured a system in which the United States, the United Kingdom, the Soviet Union and China would keep the peace through permanent consultation among themselves. The Security Council, with its permanent members and the veto, embodies that idea, he said.
The substance of the claim, as TASS reports it, is that the three leaders committed in Shenzhen, as permanent members of the Security Council, to reform the UN so that it can fulfil its fundamental mission of international peace and security. That is a significant assertion, because the three countries hold vetoes that have repeatedly blocked action in the Council, and any reform of the body's structure or working methods would require agreement among the permanent members themselves.
Much, however, is not established by the material available. The report does not describe the text of the Declaration toward Peace, the specific reforms contemplated, or any timetable. It does not say whether the commitment was recorded in a joint document or characterised by the three governments in the same terms Sachs uses. Nor does it indicate how other permanent members, Britain and France, or the wider UN membership, would be involved in a process framed around a concert of three powers. The account rests on a single expert's interpretation, offered to a Russian outlet, rather than on official communiqués from the capitals concerned.
The wider significance lies in the framing. A concert-of-powers model would shift weight within the international system toward the three largest military powers and away from the broader membership on which much of the UN's legitimacy rests. For Moscow, Washington and Beijing, the appeal may be a Council that acts where their interests converge and deadlocks less visibly where they do not. Whether Shenzhen proves a starting point for institutional change or a rhetorical gesture will depend on documents and follow-up meetings not yet in evidence.



