Sunday 22 November 2026 Live: Iran war Stories Browse Wire Subscribe
Faultline Journal — home

DiplomacyAnalysis

Grynspan Leads the UN Race, but a Veto Stands in Her Way

The Costa Rican diplomat tops Security Council straw polls to become the first woman secretary-general, yet at least one permanent member remains opposed.

Grynspan Leads the UN Race, but a Veto Stands in Her Way

Image: Al Jazeera

Reporting drawn from Al Jazeera. Analysis and editorial framing by the Faultline Journal Editorial Desk.

The UN must become less risk-averse. Its biggest risk today is the risk of not trying.

Rebeca Grynspan keeps coming out ahead. In straw poll after straw poll among members of the UN Security Council, according to Al Jazeera, the Costa Rican diplomat has emerged ahead of all other candidates to succeed Antonio Guterres as secretary-general. If she wins, the current head of the UN's trade body would become the first woman and the first Jewish person to hold the post. The deadline for a decision is 31 December.

Yet frontrunner status has not converted into a win. At least one veto stands against her candidature, Al Jazeera reports. With secret ballots, eight candidates in all and the rivalries of the five permanent members in play, there is no public confirmation of which of them opposes her. The report does not identify the vetoing state, and no official account of the ballot has been published.

Her record cuts both ways. As secretary-general of the UN Conference on Trade and Development since 2021, she is a UN insider, and she is widely credited with a role in the Black Sea Grain Initiative, which allowed Ukrainian agricultural exports through the Black Sea during the war. Al Jazeera reports that she negotiated the deal while undergoing breast cancer treatment. According to UNCTAD, the initiative exported 32 million tonnes of grain and lowered global food prices by 22 percent before Russia withdrew a year later. Her criticism of that withdrawal could incline Moscow to veto her, Richard Gowan of the International Crisis Group has told Al Jazeera. She met Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov in April.

Her background carries other weight. The daughter of Polish Jewish refugees who fled to Central America during the Holocaust, she has close family ties to Israel and studied there. Her position on the war in Gaza has broadly aligned with the UN's: she condemned Hamas's October 2023 attack and called for a ceasefire. Under her leadership, UNCTAD has published reports warning of the collapse of the Palestinian economy under Israeli occupation, including a February report estimating cumulative losses of $212.2bn from 2000 to 2024.

The larger obstacle may be Washington. Al Jazeera frames her task as winning over Donald Trump, a president it describes as intent on dismantling the very organisation she hopes to lead. Grynspan's answer is a case for reform and appetite for risk. "The UN must become less risk-averse," she told Al Jazeera. "Its biggest risk today is the risk of not trying." She argues that any mediator knows ten ideas may fail before the eleventh succeeds, and that few governments can bear the political cost of so many rejections, while the secretary-general can.

What remains unknown is decisive. The identity of the vetoing power, the state of the lobbying and whether a credible alternative can gather the required nine votes without a veto are all unconfirmed. The contest will be settled in private, and the public record offers little more than the polls and the candidates' own words.

United NationsGrynspanSecurity CouncilUNCTADUnited States