The court did not decide whether Vermont law recognises civil extortion as a cause of action in its own right.
The Vermont Supreme Court has affirmed a lower court judgment in a long-running property dispute that began with the sale of 42 acres in Royalton and ended with jury awards to three men on three separate claims. According to the Times of India, citing the November 13, 2026, decision in Lamson v. Goode, the court upheld $15,100 for civil extortion in favour of subcontractor Chase Locke, $7,500 for breach of contract in favour of Gregory Lamson and $5,000 for assault in favour of James Goode. It also upheld the denial of attorney's fees to both Lamson and Goode under Vermont's Prompt Pay Act.
The facts are tangled. Lamson sold the land to Goode in 2015, then was hired by Goode to build a pond on another property. Lamson subcontracted Locke to clear the site, and separately hired him to cut timber on Lamson's own land. Disagreements over payment, the unfinished pond and the use of equipment followed, and Lamson sued both men in 2017. Goode counterclaimed for assault; Locke claimed unpaid logging work and alleged that Lamson had threatened to report him to police and his parole officer unless he handed over money and property, including a storage locker.
The extortion award was the most closely watched point on appeal. Lamson argued that Vermont's criminal extortion statute does not create a separate civil right to sue, and the trial court initially agreed before allowing the claim to reach the jury. The justices sidestepped that question. They found that Vermont precedent permits recovery of money or property transferred under economic duress, and that the jury had been instructed to award Locke the value of what he had handed over. On that restitutionary basis, the award stood. The court did not decide whether Vermont law recognises civil extortion as a cause of action in its own right.
The fee ruling turned on discretion. Both Lamson and Goode sought costs under the Prompt Pay Act, which can provide fees where a party substantially prevails in a construction payment dispute. The trial court found neither had won decisively enough, and the Supreme Court held that this judgment lay within its discretion. The court also noted that Lamson had failed to preserve his challenge to the amount of damages through a timely post-trial motion and had not ordered a transcript of the relevant testimony.
The case matters less for its sums than for what it leaves open. Vermont's highest court has preserved a restitutionary route to recovery in coercion claims without settling the underlying question of whether civil extortion exists. For builders, subcontractors and landowners, the practical lesson is procedural: preserve objections, order the transcript, and expect fee awards under the Prompt Pay Act to turn on the trial judge's assessment of who really won. The decision is available on Justia, according to the report.


