Sunday 22 November 2026 Live: Iran war Stories Browse Wire Subscribe
Faultline Journal — home

PoliticsAnalysis

New South Wales Retreats on Underquoting Rules as Election Nears

The Minns government has paused laws to protect homebuyers after agents in the premier's own electorate raised concerns about a falling market.

New South Wales Retreats on Underquoting Rules as Election Nears

Reporting drawn from The Guardian World. Analysis and editorial framing by the Faultline Journal Editorial Desk.

The laws and the fines attached to them will now be paused for up to a year.

The New South Wales government has shelved laws designed to protect homebuyers from underquoting, after the premier, Chris Minns, said real estate agents in his own Sydney electorate had raised concerns about their effect amid a housing downturn. According to The Guardian, the changes were due to take effect on Tuesday and would have barred agents from advertising a property below a written offer the seller had already rejected, with fines of up to $110,000 or three times an agent's commission, whichever was greater.

The laws and the fines attached to them will now be paused for up to a year. Minns told reporters on Monday morning that the issue had come across his desk from agents in Kogarah, his south Sydney seat, after he was asked about fears the rules could stop sellers advertising at a lower rate now that the market has fallen. Home values in Sydney have dropped 10.1 per cent from their 2026 peak, according to data from Cotality cited in the report.

The premier described the difficulty as an unforeseen consequence, saying it was not the fault of the seller or the agent if prices were dropping, and that the legislation had at least intuitively assumed prices would always rise. The changes had been passed in June and were modelled on laws already in force in Victoria, where additional transparency measures took effect last month: sellers must reveal their reserve price at least a week before a sale, and agents must publish sale prices once a transaction is completed.

The reversal is awkward for the fair trading and corrections minister, Anoulack Chanthivong, who had praised the laws as recently as 1 November as important reforms to put the hammer down on underquoting and stop homebuyers being taken for a ride. A spokesperson for the government later provided a statement from the minister saying the laws had been passed at a different time and in a different economic and housing market, and that the government did not want laws meant to protect homebuyers to inadvertently make it harder for them to buy. The report notes that Chanthivong has previously been overruled by Minns on rental and prison reforms, and faces a preselection battle in his seat of Macquarie Fields; the premier would not say whether he would intervene on the minister's behalf.

The decision is one of several recent backdowns by the government, which faces a state election in March under pressure from One Nation and the Coalition over the cost of living and pressures on small business. Last month it dropped parts of plastics legislation that would have required cafes to offer dine-in customers mugs and glasses instead of takeaway cups. Labor's internal polling has suggested One Nation could win more than 20 lower house seats, and a Sydney Morning Herald Resolve poll in October put One Nation on 26 per cent of the primary vote, behind Labor on 30 per cent and ahead of the Coalition on 23 per cent.

What the report does not establish is how the pause will be reviewed, whether the laws will return in their current form, or what evidence beyond the concerns of agents in one electorate drove the timing. Those questions will shape how buyers and the industry read the retreat as the election approaches.

New South WaleshousingunderquotingChris Minnselections