Sunday 22 November 2026 Live: Iran war Stories Browse Wire Subscribe
Faultline Journal — home

PoliticsAnalysis

Arizona Gate Dispute: Appeals Court Rejects HOA Arbitration Clause

Judges rule one-sided arbitration rules cannot be enforced against homeowners seeking wider gate for their disabled son's golf cart.

Arizona Gate Dispute: Appeals Court Rejects HOA Arbitration Clause

Reporting drawn from Times of India World. Analysis and editorial framing by the Faultline Journal Editorial Desk.

Homeowners could be pushed into private arbitration; the HOA kept the courthouse door open.

A couple in Arizona have won a round in their legal fight with their homeowners' association over a backyard gate, after the state's Court of Appeals refused to force them into private arbitration. According to the Times of India, Kevin and Jennifer LoPresto asked the Wigwam Creek South Community Association in November 2024 for permission to replace their single gate with a wider double gate so that their disabled son could park his golf cart in the backyard. The association refused, and the couple sued in April 2025, accusing the HOA of breaching its contractual duties and of failing to enforce its rules fairly, impartially and without selective enforcement.

The association then sought to move the dispute out of the courts, pointing to arbitration provisions in the community's Declaration of Covenants, Conditions and Restrictions and in a second document, the Guidelines for Community Living. The trial judge declined to order arbitration, and declined again on reconsideration. The HOA appealed. In a memorandum decision dated 25 September 2026, the appeals court backed the lower court, finding that the arbitration rules used by the association were one-sided and could not be enforced against the couple. The judges also granted the LoPrestos reasonable legal fees and costs tied to the appeal.

The reasoning turns on symmetry. The court noted that Arizona law generally favours written arbitration agreements as a quicker, cheaper route to resolving disputes, but that such agreements must meet basic fairness standards. Citing an earlier Arizona case, Stevens/Leinweber/Sullens, Inc. v. Holm Development and Management, Inc., the judges held that a one-sided arbitration rule can be substantively unconscionable. Under the community's main declaration, homeowners had to take their claims to arbitration, while a separate subsection excused the association from the same requirement and allowed it to go to court to enforce the rules. Homeowners could be pushed into private arbitration; the HOA kept the courthouse door open.

The association argued that Section V of its community guidelines was a separate and more specific rule that survived even if the main declaration's clause fell. The appeals court did not need to resolve questions about whether that section had been properly approved, because it found another flaw in the wording: the rule applied when any owner had a dispute with the HOA, imposing binding arbitration on homeowners but not on the association when it took legal action against a resident. For the same reason as the main clause, Section V was held unfair and unenforceable.

The immediate effect is procedural. The LoPrestos can continue their case in open court rather than before a private arbitrator, and the association must bear the costs of the appeal. The ruling does not decide whether the HOA was wrong to refuse the wider gate, nor does it establish a general right for residents to alter their properties. What it does signal is that Arizona courts will scrutinise arbitration clauses embedded in community governing documents when the obligations run in one direction only. The decision is a memorandum decision, and the report does not say whether the association intends to seek further review or to settle the underlying claim.

ArizonaHOAarbitrationhousingcourts