Sunday 22 November 2026 Live: Iran war Stories Browse Wire Subscribe
Faultline Journal — home

EconomicsAnalysis

A Deposit Lost: Ontario Court Enforces the Terms of a Broken Property Deal

A buyer who waived financing and then walked away forfeits $70,000, as an Ontario court holds sellers to a contract she had already abandoned.

A Deposit Lost: Ontario Court Enforces the Terms of a Broken Property Deal

Reporting drawn from Times of India World. Analysis and editorial framing by the Faultline Journal Editorial Desk.

The ruling turns on a familiar principle rather than any novel question of law: a firm contract binds, and a buyer who removes a financing condition carries the risk of her own funding.

A buyer who agreed to purchase a $1.388 million home in Vaughan, Ontario, and then could not secure a mortgage has been ordered to forfeit her $70,000 deposit and pay the sellers $35,000 in costs, according to a report in the Times of India citing court records published by the Canadian Legal Information Institute. The Ontario Superior Court of Justice found that Reesa Garber's emails amounted to an anticipatory breach of contract, and that Sharon and Alexander Laraia were entitled to keep the deposit.

The sequence of events matters. Garber, a registered real estate agent in Ontario, offered $1,388,000 for 81 Littleriver Court on 28 April 2024, and the sellers accepted. The agreement carried a financing condition until 3 May 2024, and on that date she fulfilled it and removed the financial terms, making the contract firm. The deposit was paid and held in the brokerage's trust account, with completion set for 16 July 2024. On 13 June she told the sellers' listing agent that she was struggling to sell her own property and could not obtain mortgage financing, and that she needed that sale to fund the purchase. The agreement, the report notes, did not make the purchase conditional on the sale of her home. The sellers said they would hold her to the contract.

Further messages followed. On 14 June she told the office of the real estate lawyer Giancarlo Soppelsa that she could not obtain financing and would be unable to complete, and asked either to terminate the agreement or extend the completion date. The sellers refused both. On 21 June she repeated that she could not complete; on 24 June she sent a signed mutual release and demanded the property be immediately relisted to mitigate damages; on 26 June, through counsel, she again said she would not complete. The sellers' lawyer wrote on 27 June that her conduct amounted to an anticipatory breach, accepted the breach and reserved the sellers' right to seek damages and forfeiture of the deposit. Justice André found the messages clear and unequivocal.

The court rejected Garber's argument that her later attempts to obtain financing and arrange an appraisal revived the agreement, holding that the sellers had no contractual obligation to provide access to the property for financing purposes after the agreement had ended. The sellers had offered on 3 July 2024 to revive the transaction on new terms, including an additional $20,000 deposit and a direction releasing the deposit if the purchase failed to close again. Garber did not accept, and the judge found that the failed attempt to revive the deal did not change the consequences of her earlier breach.

The ruling turns on a familiar principle rather than any novel question of law: a firm contract binds, and a buyer who removes a financing condition carries the risk of her own funding. The Times of India attaches a disclaimer that it has not independently verified the details of the transaction, the parties or the proceedings, and the account rests on CanLII's publication of the decision. What is not established in the material is whether any appeal has been filed, or how the forfeited deposit compares with the sellers' eventual resale of the property. The costs are to be paid within 90 days.

Canadapropertycontract lawmortgagesOntario